If my VM's get compromised my Ci/CD creates a new one. But that's because it treats my infra as cattle

When virtual machines (VMs) are compromised in a CI/CD environment, treating infrastructure as “cattle”—where resources are easily replaceable rather than precious—can be a strategic approach.
Here’s how i think to effectively manage compromised VMs and the rationale behind this methodology.

Understanding the “Cattle vs. Pets” Paradigm

In the context of IT infrastructure:

  • Cattle refers to resources that can be easily created, destroyed, and replaced. This approach emphasizes automation and scalability.
  • Pets are unique resources that require careful management and maintenance, often leading to significant downtime and recovery efforts when compromised.

By treating VMs as cattle, organizations can quickly spin up new instances when a VM is breached, minimizing downtime and reducing the risk of lingering threats.

Steps to Take When a VM is Compromised

  1. Assess the Situation: Determine the extent of the compromise. This includes evaluating whether sensitive data has been accessed or if there are backdoors left by attackers.

  2. Destroy the Compromised VM: Since manual repairs may not guarantee complete security, it is often safer to delete the compromised VM entirely. This eliminates any potential hidden threats.

  3. Deploy a New VM: Use automated CI/CD pipelines to quickly provision a new VM from a clean image or template. This process should include:

    • Ensuring that the new instance is fully patched and updated.
    • Implementing security best practices from the outset, such as using strong authentication methods and network isolation.
  4. Restore Data if Necessary: If data recovery is needed, consider attaching existing disks from the compromised VM to the new instance, provided that those disks have not been affected by the compromise.

  5. Implement Monitoring and Alerts: Enhance security measures by integrating monitoring tools that can alert you to suspicious activities in real time, helping prevent future compromises.

Benefits of Treating VMs as Cattle

  • Speed of Recovery: Quickly replacing compromised VMs reduces downtime and helps maintain operational continuity.
  • Cost Efficiency: Automating VM deployment can lower operational costs by reducing manual intervention and streamlining processes.
  • Security Posture Improvement: Regularly cycling through VMs ensures that outdated or vulnerable configurations are less likely to persist in your environment.

In conclusion, treating VMs as cattle allows for a more resilient infrastructure in CI/CD environments. By implementing swift remediation strategies and focusing on automation, organizations can effectively manage security incidents while maintaining productivity.

In DevOps you want everything to be destroyed as the same way you’ve created your infra. That’s why most companies nowadays use IaC to create or manage their (cloud) infrastructure

If your infra is written from IaC you can make or destroy it whenever you want however you want.

Building infrastructure is easy nowadays. Plenty of github projects that can help any developer build a complete multi zone redundant cloud infra. But it’s not about the infrastructure but the platform as a whole.

The platform would be: infrastructure and observability of said infrastructure.

That’s why platform engineering is the next step after DevSecOps.

1 Like